Notification feed is really confusing

Here’s a regular thing that happens to me:

  1. I see a notification indicator on the left navigation
  2. I click through to the notification screen
  3. I notice I have already seen the notifications at the top
  4. I scroll around, trying to figure out what’s actually new
  5. Most of the time I find something
  6. I’m never sure I’ve seen everything new

Grouping notifications by type is confusing, since I can never really be sure I’ve acknowledged everything. Either of these two different approaches would be better for me:

A. Don’t group anything. Just a steady, chronological stream of likes, new patrons, dropped patrons, thread comments.

B. Group, but keep unseen and seen notifications separate. Never group them. So if I have 30 post comments, but only 3 of them are new, I’d see two items: the 3 new posts grouped, and the 27 old ones grouped.


A post was merged into an existing topic: Notifications page needs work